From Photophone of 19th Century =>The masters of light: 20th Century Ambassador of Collaboration, Networking and Communication in 21st Century !!!

Two Revolutionary Optical Technologies: "for groundbreaking achievements concerning the transmission of light in fibers for optical communication" + "for the invention of an imaging semiconductor circuit – the CCD sensor"

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Question for online poll on the sidelines of this year`s Physics Nobel announcements was asked is this: “Did you know that this question comes to you via glass fibre?” The mere words reflecting the kind of revolutionary character the invention Charles K. Kao gifted to this world ! He initiated search for and the development of the low-loss optical fiber presently used in optical fiber communication systems. On the other hand ‘The Sailer Man’ George E. Smith who submitted thesis of three pages to University of Chicago says that ideas of the charged couple devices actually came from his head when he was deleivering one lecture on invention. He even don`t remember exactly how many patents he held with his colleague Willard S. Boyle at Bell Labs in 60s , 70s, 80s. Willard S. Boyle and George E. Smith invented the charge-coupled device (CCD) presently used in many digital cameras and in advanced medical and scientific instrumentation.

These three who are recipient of this year`s Physics Nobel are the people who are responsible for shaping modern information technology to present stage. Kao’s discoveries have paved the way for optical fiber technology, which today is used for almost all telephony and data communication. Boyle and Smith have invented a digital image sensor – CCD, or charge-coupled device – which today has become an electronic eye in almost all areas of photography.

Underlying the historical feature of the Kao`s work Nobel Foundation says, “When the Nobel Prize in Physics is announced in Stockholm, a large part of the world receives the message almost instantly. At almost the speed of light, the highest of speeds, the message is spread around the world. Text, images, speech and video are shuffled around in optical fibers and through space, and are received instantly in small and convenient devices. It is something that many people have already come to take for granted. The optical fiber has been a prerequisite for this extremely rapid development in the field of communications, a development that Charles Kao predicted over 40 years ago.”

Kao worked for Standard Telecommunication Laboratories Harlow, United Kingdom and Chinese University of Hong Kong. Charles K. Kao was a young engineer at STL working on optical communication. Kao was born in 1933 in Shanghai, China, educated in Hong-Kong and graduated in Electrical Engineering in 1957 at University of London and got a PhD at the University of London in 1965. With the help of colleague Hockham whose work on the analysis of the effect of waveguide imperfections lead them to a thesis defended in 1969. They investigated in detail the fundamental properties of optical fibers with respect to optical communication.

Just around that time, Willard Boyle and George Smith radically altered the conditions for the field of photography, because film is no longer needed in cameras where the images can be captured electronically with an image sensor. The electronic eye, the CCD, became the first truly successful technology for the digital transfer of images. It opened the door to a daily stream of images, which is filling up the optical fiber cables. Only optical fiber is capable of transferring such large quantities of data that electronic image sensor technology yields.

100 years ago, G. Marconi and K.F. Braun were awarded the Nobel prize “in recognition of their contributions to the development of wireless telegraphy”. 50 years ago, electronic and radio communications were in rapid expansion. The first transatlantic cable was installed in 1956 and satellites would soon allow even better coverage. The first communication satellite was launched in 1958. Research in telecommunication concentrated mainly in shorter radio waves, in the millimeter range, with the aim to reach higher transmission speeds. These waves could not travel as easily in air as longer waves, and the research focused on designing practical waveguides. The invention of the laser in the early 1960s (Nobel Prize in 1964 to C.H. Townes, N.G. Basov and A.M. Prokhorov) gave a new boost to the research in optical communication. ¹ Previous use of optical fibres was limited to medical use for industrial manufacturing of instruments for gastroscopy and other medical uses.

Global communication, and in particular internet and long-distance telephony, is now based primarily on optical fiber technology. The main advantage of optical waves compared to radio waves is the high frequencies that allow high data transmission rate. Nowadays, several terabits per second can be transmitted in a single fiber which represents an increase by a factor of one million to what could be achieved fifty years ago with radio signal transmission. The number of optical fiber cables being installed all over the world is increasing rapidly. Fiber optics has also been important for a huge number of other applications, in medicine, laser technology and sensors.


Different schemes for color photography were also explored during the 19th century. G. Lippman was awarded the 1908 Nobel Prize in Physics for his color photographic process based on interference effects. W.H.F. Talbot invented in 1841, thus initiating modern photography, light sensitive papers containing silver salts for first obtaining a negative image and thereafter, through contact copying with another light sensitive paper, a positive image. He described also the steps necessary to develop the latent images formed in the papers. Several developments followed regarding the substrate used for the light sensitive layers. The idea to use emulsions (silver salts in gelatin) to create negatives was conceived around 1870 and the replacement of glass plates with a celluloid film around 1880. The roll of film was invented 1887 by a priest, H. Goodwin, and explored by G. Eastman. In 1888 the Eastman Kodak box camera for roll film appeared on the market. Different schemes for color photography were also explored during the 19th century. G. Lippman was awarded the 1908 Nobel Prize in Physics for his color photographic process based on interference effects.


Willard S. Boyle and George E. Smith were both at Bell Laboratories, New Jersey when they conceived the CCD device. The CCD is a metal-oxide semiconductor (MOS) device that can be used as a detector to record images in electronic form, and thus it offers a modern alternative to the photographic film. A CCD can record a scene by accumulating light induced charges over its semiconductor surface, and by transporting them to be read out at the edge of the light sensitive area. The invention utilized the properties of the then new MOS (Metal Oxide Semiconductor) technology to create an integrated and simple device to record and read out a scene. The read-out is similar to a fashion often referred to as a “bucket brigade” as it shifts arrays of information by successive site shift.

The hour long discussion between Boyle and Smith in 1969 led to an enormous development of practical and scientific instrumentation based on CCDs: digital cameras, medical devices and high performance scientific instrumentation, not least for astronomy and astrophysics. There are several important medical applications for CCD cameras, e.g. for the study of tissues and cells as imaging devices in microscopes or for the recording of cells and tissue. Digital photography has also revolutionized almost all image based medical diagnostic tools. A large application is found in endoscopy for inspections inside the body and for guidance during micro- or ‘key hole’- surgery. There are many types of endoscopes, e.g. based on single optical fibers, optical fiber bundles or in the form of capsules possible to swallow with built in light source, CCD sensors and wireless signal transmission.

Solid-state image sensors and digital cameras have changed the role of images in our society, since they give electronic signals, digits, which can easily be transmitted and treated. In science, the possibility of transferring and processing images digitally is a real revolution. Digital image processing is now a global commodity which enables, for instance, the best international expertise to be involved in crucial diagnostic and even surgical situations, through remote control and feedback through digital cameras. Furthermore the evaluation of large amounts of data (e.g. created in mapping the universe) can be spread to many groups and even to volunteers from the general public; and no doubt this dissemination will take place of course due to the grace of Optical Fibres invented by Dr. Kao.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1 THE ROYAL SWEDISH ACADEMY OF SCIENCES, Scientific Background on the Nobel Prize in Physics 2009, TWO REVOLUT IONARY OPTICAL TECHNOLOGIES, 6 October 2009

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"Abhi to main jawan hoon..." + "how chromosomes are protected by telomeres and the enzyme telomerase"

When Elizabeth Blackburn last visited India on a lecture tour, introductory note inviting for her lecture read: "Nehru Memorial Museum and Library: Award-winning biologist and professor at University of California Elizabeth Blackburn will speak on “Chromosome Ends and Human Health and Disease”, Teen Murti Auditorium, Teen Murti House, 4:30 p.m."After following this and her non-stop talk lasting above an hour, it was clear how she was successfull in radiating her energy in jargon-less presentation along with consistent enthusiasm to appeal girls and young minds to take a giant leap to study this area which ultimately marched towards Nobel of 2009.


Significance of the discovery made by Elizabeth H. Blackburn, Carol W. Greider and Jack W. Szostak can be guaged from the starting words of the press release: "This year's Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine is awarded to three scientists who have solved a major problem in biology: how the chromosomes can be copied in a complete way during cell divisions and how they are protected against degradation. The Nobel Laureates have shown that the solution is to be found in the ends of the chromosomes – the telomeres – and in an enzyme that forms them – telomerase." (http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/medicine/laureates/2009/press.html


This is the first time that two women are sharing the Nobel prize in entire history of Nobel prizes. The discovery is key in finding many answers of ageing and decay of immune system in cancer. As release further elaborates, "If the telomeres are shortened, cells age. Conversely, if telomerase activity is high, telomere length is maintained, and cellular senescence is delayed. This is the case in cancer cells, which can be considered to have eternal life. Certain inherited diseases, in contrast, are characterized by a defective telomerase, resulting in damaged cells. The award of the Nobel Prize recognizes the discovery of a fundamental mechanism in the cell, a discovery that has stimulated the development of new therapeutic strategies."


This award also reflects inspiring story of student and teacher sharing the hallmark of greatest glory in scientific acheivement. Carol Greider who is Proffessor of Molecular Biology in Johns Hopkins University and Genetics will be sharing prize with Szostak was graduate student of third co-winner Blackburn and she completed Ph.D. from California University, Berkeley.


The efforts directed at approaching path breaking solutions to cancers can be understood from her words: "To understand how telomere functions to provide chromosome stability and how telomerase might play a role in cancer, we generated a telomerase null mouse. Mice that lack the gene encoding the mouse Telomerase RNA (mTR) show progressive telomere shorting during successive breeding. The mice are viable for up to six generations although in the later generations there is severe reduction in fertility due to apoptosis in the germ cells. Crosses of these telomerase null mice to other tumor prone mouse models suggest that under some circumstances tumor formation can be greatly reduced when telomerase is absent. This suggests that telomerase inhibition may be a useful approach to cancer treatment." (http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/pharmacology/research/greider.html)


Third legend in the group is Jack W. Sztostak in Department of Genetics & Molecular Biology at Cambridge St. A Ph.D. from Cornell University, this man is member of all premier acadamies like National Academy of Sceinces, American Academy of Arts and Sciences and New York Academy of Sciences.

"At the outset of his career, Szostak made pioneering contributions to the field of genetics. His discoveries helped clarify the events that lead to chromosomal recombination—the reshuffling of genes that occurs during meiosis—and the function of telomeres, the specialized DNA sequences at the tips of chromosomes. He is also credited with the construction of the world's first yeast artificial chromosome. That feat helped scientists to map the location of genes in mammals and to develop techniques for manipulating genes. " (http://www.hhmi.org/research/investigators/szostak_bio.html)

But a Nobel Prize–winning discovery in the 1980s by former HHMI President Tom Cech and Sidney Altman transformed Szostak`s research. This discovery demonstrated that RNA, the sister molecule of DNA, can catalyze certain chemical reactions inside cells, a job previously thought to be the exclusive domain of proteins. This new revelation about RNA's dual role suggested to some scientists, including Szostak, that RNA likely existed long before DNA or proteins because it might be able to catalyze its own reproduction. Their discovery made it easier to think about the origin of life. (life.http://www.hhmi.org/research/investigators/szostak.html)

Blackburn who is distnguished recipient of six honorary doctorates from renowned universities, not to mention the legendary awards and membership from across the world. Most importantly her research vindicates other scientist`s work focussing on potential of diet, exercise, stress reduction and other "lifestyle interventions" in reducing the risk of and reverse damage from coronary artery disease and stave off diabetes. She was consistently emphasising on this mind-body link now being fertile territory for prominent research scientists when she referred to her experience during the talk she delievered few months ago in India.
(Her major list of publications is available at http://cancer.ucsf.edu/people/blackburn_elizabeth.php.)


Fountain of Youth:
In a recent interview she says, "For now, the best defense is healthy living, she said. The goal should not be to live to 150 years old but to live well for 80 or 90 years. In an ideal world, people would protect their telomeres during the years they're normally susceptible to diseases of aging. Then they would "fall off the perch" and die, as genetically programmed, at 90 or even 100 years old. Scientists used to believe that everyone's telomere length shortened over time, the same way they used to think that brain neurons stopped growing in the elderly. But telomere length, while it does decline in general, fluctuates in individuals. Many older people have relatively long telomeres. Eventually she indicates towards a way where drugs will play a lesser role and study of our body's physiology should play a major role in enabling us to arrive at a age when we will sing "Abhi to main jawan hoon..." "(http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2009/01/02/CMBO14L1P9.DTL&type=health)

============================================================================

Stars of This year`s Shantiswaroop Bhatnagar Prizes by CSIR

PIB reported late on 26^th Sept. 2009 about eleven scientist being selected for 2009 Shanti Swarup Bhatnagar Prize for science and technology on the occasion of CSIR Foundation Day celebration here in New Delhi at Vigyan Bhawan. Their names discipline-wise are as under: Biological Sciences: 1) Dr Amitabh Joshi, Jawaharlal Nehru Centre for Advanced Scientific Research, Banglore, 2) Dr Bhaskar Saha, National Centre for Cell Science, Pune; Chemical Sciences: 1) Dr Charusita chakravarty, Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, New Delhi, 2)Dr Narayanaswamy Jayaraman, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore; Earth, Atmosphere, Ocean & Planetary Sciences: 1) Dr S K Satheesh, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore Engineering Sciences: 1) Dr Giridhar Madras, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, 2) Dr. Jayant Ramaswamy Haritsa, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore; Mathematical Sciences: 1) Dr. Venapally Suresh, University of Hyderabad, Hyderabad; Medical Sciences: 1) Dr Santosh Gajanan Honavar, L V Prasad Eye Institute, Hyderabad; Physical Sciences: 1)Dr Rajesh Gopakumar, Harishhandra research Institute, Allahabad, 2) Dr Abhishek Dhar, Raman Research Institute, Bangalore.

The Bhatnagar Prizes are given to scientists below 45 years of age, for their outstanding scientific contributions made primarily in India during the last 5 years preceding the year of the Prize. The SSB Prize comprises a citation, a plaque and a cash award of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees five lakh only), and are given to the recipients by the Prime Minister of India.

How complex concepts in Physics like Quantum field theory and giant concept of string theory can be milked in two hours of great oratory and generate persistent curiosity in the young, old research scientists is reflected from the presentation of Dr. Gopakumar deleivered at Tata Institute of Fundamental Research on 7^th Sept. 2009. This year`s one of the winner of Shantiswaroop Bhatnagar award winner was there to present his passionate research as a part of commemorating birth centenary of Dr. Homi Bhabha.

At the outset he greatly focussed on principles of Physics embodying our ability to discern regularities amidst complex behaviour. This according to him, is remarkably capturable in precise mathematical language. Thus his belief in these principles seemingly able to continue to do so as we widen the scope of these laws though sometimes to do so requires conceptual and mathematical reorientation.

Jumping on the gravity, he tried to explain how gravity is the most ubiquitous force in nature. It is common knowledge that Newton’s law of gravitation the first “universal” law. However, he says, it has a certain range of validity and these laws break down under two different sets of extreme circumstances. What are these circumstances? “These are not applicable when objects move very fast (e.g. Pulsars) and also not relevant when the density becomes large (e.g. at the centre of galaxies).

Dr. Gopakumar further elaborated the evolution of the falsification of the Newton`s theories. Einstein succeeded in (partially) overcoming these limitations. His description of gravity applicable at high velocities (relativistic). It is also true for moderately high densities (e.g. neutron stars). This was accomplished this not just by tweaking Newton’s Law a bit. This as Dr. says radically overhauled the very framework for describing gravity. Einstein tied up the description of gravity with the geometry of space and time! Spacetime is no longer a passive stage for the drama of physical events. It becomes an active participant - responding to its contents.

He was teaching about ‘Gravity and Geometry’. Einstein’s theory is in a very different mathematical framework from Newton’s. In terms of a metric measurements of distance and curvature of spacetime; Einstein’s equations determine in terms of the matter/energy. This, remarkably enough, reduces to Newton’s law for low densities and velocities.

Then suddenly he introduced few doubts and questions like these: “Physical reality is QM’cal - classical measurables have statistical outcomes. Is spacetime a statistically averaged notion? How can we sensibly talk of quantum fluctuations of the metric? How do we reconcile Einstein’s picture with Quantum Mechanics? ” As he explains further, limitations of Einstein’s Law lead to the breakdown of Einstein’s description as you enlarge its scope again under two sets of limiting circumstances especially at very short (“planckian”) distances and at ultra-high densities. The equations themselves exhibit the breakdown - develop singularities.” Thus he manages to conclude that the need for a description that overcomes these limitations will be fulfilled by a Quantum theory of Gravity and scientists need Quantum. Gravity to investigate the birth of the universe or understand black holes.

Eventually Dr. Gopakumar names String Theory as ‘The Reluctant Radical’. Because String Theory originated as a “conservatively radical” modification of Quantum Field Theory(Q.F.T.) considering the Quantum dynamics of extended objects. This has to be understood in the context of delicately spun framework which is highly constrained - more so than Quantum Field Theory. String Theory showed early promise in addressing some of the difficulties QFT had with respect to gravity.

Recent interest in string theory is generated by variety of applications of theoretical insights scientists are getting. According to Suresh Kumar S., Scientist at NIIST , Trivendrum says¹ that the same string-theory concepts used to describe black holes can help explain the behavior of electrons in a superconductor or metal. It has been used for explaining the strong nuclear forces involved in a quark–gluon plasma, and has become a competitor for the more favored QCD theories. Multi-dimensional space, with the extra dimensions being coiled in the ordinary three dimensioned case. Under high energy conditions these express themselves. Holographic principle applies in the reverse situation of extension to cooler or less energy intense situations :information contained in a higher dimension can be embedded in lower dimension. Possibility of certain material configurations and compositions under particular conditions causing holographic effects as above is being studies, so that a higher dimensioned phenomenon is morphed onto a lower dimensioned domain.

For decades researchers have tried to wrest testable predictions from string theory, the leading candidate for a more fundamental understanding of the universe.² Now physicists say they have used one of the most sophisticated pieces of string theory to predict properties of the ultradense matter created in an atom smasher in Long Island, N.Y. If confirmed, however, the prediction would not offer evidence for string theory, which requires the existence of extra dimensions of space full of higher-dimensional stringlike objects and other widgets. Instead, it would establish that some of string theory's mathematics could be used to study the forces at work inside an atom's nucleus.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1http://www.nature.com/news/2009/090719/full/news.2009.699.html

2http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=a-prediction-from-string-t

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

-

Managing Urbanisation- Delhi Taking Lessons from Tokyo Metro: Planning Ahead of Expanding Cities

Learning about Japan`s way of "managing urbanisation in vastly populated and economically expanding cities" was a momentous experience today at second day of first Habitat Summit (Towards Alternative Urban Futures for India). Delivering a keynote address on “MAKING CITIES WORK FOR GROWTH” , Hiroto Arakawa, Senior Special Advisor, Japan International Co-operation Agency spoke in details about how Tokyo which accounts for nearly 25% of the population of Japan has established itself a model of urban transport across the world.


Managing urbanisation was biggest challenge ahead of Tokyo in the time during 1950s-70s. Government strategies were primarily focussed on sustainibility and inclusiveness. Solving congestion and reducing spatial disparity were the prime challenges in this process. By that time Tokyo-Yokohama and Osaka-kobe had emerged has leading twin cities dominating the Japanese rise lead by vibrant economic activities across the pacific coast. Due to the result of the development of these cities that Japan could become nation with second largest GNP after USA for quite a long time. How crucial these cities are to Japan is evident from recent celebration in Yokohama witnessed by me to mark the 150th year of opening of port of Yokohama to the entire world. Whole day Yokohama city was waiting for evening and when all the roads leading towards the main museum located near bridge of Yokohama port were perfectly congested to give you sense that really megacities while in time of celebration can really behave like ordinary cities. But Yokohama could survive that celebration by bringing in lakhs of commuters from Tokyo and other cities due to well meshed metro lines.


Tokyo`s population is 1.5 times that of New York but area is one third that of New York. Considering that London and Paris are much smaller than New York, Tokyo becomes the biggest Metropolitan region of the world. The vast numbers of commuters use the public transportation system at the same time each morning and evening, so railways must provide tremendous capacity to satisfy the demand. Postwar improvements in Tokyo’s railway network have involved continued effort and huge investments, creating a transit system with immense capacity (Table 3). Although the system can handle the demand, there is congestion at times but studies show that there is a limit to what can be done to alleviate this congestion. Integrated Spatial Development Plan of 1962 and New Integrated Spatial Development Plan of 1969 laid the foundation of creating urban policy and infrastructure resources necessary for the expansion of the metro service.


Government`s flexibility to award contracts to private railway developers accelerated the development of Tokyo city itself. Private metro construction companies initiated for large scale infrastructure development around metro station areas, social infrastructure like housing development recieved impetus by these private industries and not least these companies were instrumental in erecting the economical bus transport in the cities being developed around new metro stations. Subways became the focus of most new railway construction in metropolitan areas after second world war. Due to immense expensive subway development, companies borrowed money from local governments causing stalling of the work for many years. Around 1962 central government introduced new subsidy system to lighten the burden of the companies.


Real boost to Tokyo`s suburban metro development got in 1964 when Japan was responsible for successful completion of Tokyo olympics. This year Japan saw the emergence of fastest MagLev train 'Shinkansen' In all these developments, strong leadership role of central government is in addressing the fiscal space is central in solving the problem well before planning became. Once again optimising the role of central and local governments is the key as evident from the subsidies given to provate metro rail developers: one third is given by Tokyo Metropolitan Authority, one third is given by Central Government. The companies greatly increased the value of fixed assets used for non-railway businesses, and the value of their investment securities.


Average distance between two stations around Tokyo is around 0.6 miles. Metro expansion began when population density was low. Due to timely steps taken soon metro became centre of urban attraction and proved to be reason for business of profitability. More through operations linking subways, JNR lines, JR east lines, and private lines have been established since the 1960s in order to minimize the inconvinience for commuters changing trains and to reduce station congestion. Investment in Tokyo`s public transport recieves different types of assistance, reflecting the variety of different operators and conditions. Asistance include subway construction subsidies, low interest and interest free government loans to transport operators, subsidisation of interest payments by private railways and subsidies for new transport systems funded by fuel taxes. These days according to 2008 figures Tokyo Metro made sales up to the tune of $3.8 B out of which they could secure net profit upto $0.4 B.


The highlights of the session were the key points summarised by Prof. K.C. Sivaramakrishnan, Chairman, Centre for Policy Research. The points which are: (i) Whether we want to move people and goods, or move vehicles? (ii) About 20-60% of our country’s population still walks, (iii) Private cars still dominate the
urban mode of transport with 263 cars and 433 two-wheelers being added per day in 2003-04, (iv) the politics of road space allocation, (v) the politics of road space pricing, (vi) the politics of public and private funding where the tax system disfavours public transport, (vii) the politics of mass transit choices, (viii) the politics of route choices, (ix) Phase I of JNNURM: Where 15,260 buses will be brought in, but where is the space? and (x) the politics of real estate and city planning: With inter and intra-city implications. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For Further Readings:
1.Haruya Hirooka, March 2000, The Development of Tokyo’s Rail Network, Japan Railway & Transport Review 23

2.Takao Okamoto and Norihisa Tadakoshi, October 2000, Rail Transport in The World’s Major Cities, Japan Railway & Transport Review 25
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Enthusing the legacy of Homi Bhabha in young scientists of India !!!

Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai recently conducted a four day Young Indian Scientists Colloquium to commemorate birth centenary of Dr. Homi Bhabha,founder of country`s nuclear energy programme and one of the greatest theoretical and applied research scientist India has ever produced.


Colloquium`s inaugural talk was by Mahindra Agrawal from IIT, Kanpur who elaborated on the principle of N being not equal to NP. The founding assumption behind this formula is that finding the correct solution may take a very long time when n is very large. On the contrary given the solution of the puzzle it is very easy to verify if the solution of the puzzle is correct. In many problems, finding a solution is far more difficult than checking the correctness of a given solution. This is understandable because discovering a solution is often much more difficult than verifying the correctness. This emphasis by Dr. Agrawal was in reference to the efficiency of omputational power of the modern processors some of which use algorithms in sequential manner. An algorithm being a set of precise instructions in terms of arithmetic, assignments and Boolean operations.


In majority of the computational exercises the time complexity of the sequential operations is principle hindrance in enhancing the efficiency of the operations. A problem with very high complexity of the order of 1000 power is extremely difficult to solve although it does not arise in practise. The core of this discussion lies in the belief that if P is equal to NP (P=NP) then “for all problems whose solutions can be efficiently verified, then the solutions can be efficiently generated too. This is fundamental problem in contemporary research in computer science facing these days.


The progress in current research in String Theory was highlighted by Mr. Rajesh Gopakumar from Harishchandra Research Institute of Allahabad. He started off with expressing the special characteristics of laws of physics which award us the opportunity to embody our ability to discern regularities amidst complex behaviour. Further laws of physics are remarkably capturable in precise mathematical language.


This talk highlighted the successive failures of Newtonian and Eienstienian frameworks in understanding the behaviour of bodies in very fast velocities, ultra-high density and very short Planckian distances. The previously discussed aspect of verification vs. success in generating solutions (N=NP) to the problem was underlined by Dr. Gopakumar by saying that “it is discouraging that ideas to solve the latest puzzles of String Theory and it`s reation to Quantum Field are subject to inadequacy of Newton and Eienstien`s frameworks.”


The hallmark of the Colloquium can be attributed to the presentation of Dr. Shubha Tole from Dept. of Biological Sciences, TIFR. She discussed about current efforts to understand how the brain is built? The building up of vertebral cortex which is responsible for psychological features of perception, language, learning, memory and finally cognition is very much at the core of realising the possibilities to answer the long vexed questions of what is the intelligence and common sense, how we form our intuitions, where exactly the connection between neurons is established to forge a concrete decision making arrangement etc.


The keen observation behind the belief to describe the commonality of the behavioural patterns being same across different systems. The crux of the talk was focussed on the question of what would happen if LhX2 mutant cells were sprinkled in a background of normal cells of the brain. This talk was really the indicator of how complex biological topic about cortex, neurons, axons and functioning of brain can be made enjoyable through proactive body language, engaging audience in multiple interactions probing their information level about the topic being discussed and energised approach of enthusiasm.


In another interesting talk about Liquid-liquid transactions and Anomalous properties of water, silicon and other tetrahedral liquids was delivered by Srikanth Shastry of Jawaharlal Nehru Centre for Advanced Research, Bengaluru. The main theme of this research concerns about why do temperature and pressure matter when we talk about phase transition? How do the other phases of water arise like metastable states.


Water phase diagram reveals rich crystal ‘polymorphism’ and current research is trying to find out the various reasons associated with this phenomenon. For many positive reasons liquid-solid transitions work for better ways than anticipated. These coexistent lines are possible because they have same energy level. For success in getting fresh insight in the abnormal behaviour of water this free energy barrier need to be crossed. It is significant that liquid-gas coexistence line terminates at a critical point beyond which there is no distinction between liquid and gas.


Metastable state is basically where matter can exist in a state that is not the thermodynamically stable state. Such metastable states can survive for long times, but will eventually transform to the stable state, either on contact with the stable phase, spontaneously, or when “disturbed” in some way e.g. Nucleation. Research around metastability is focussed on what happens when coexistence line is crossed. It remains to be conclusively state that whether these metastable states are having finite time or not. In this respect four basic properties of liquid need to be studies in details. Properties are: density, coefficient of thermal expansion, compressibility, specific heat and many other properties show dynamic behaviour at low temperature.


Eventually talk summarised that an unusual transition between two forms of liquid water appears to be present, though not conclusively proved experimentally. Consistent (though not unique) explanation of many interesting observations in super - cooled water is being given. Computer simulation studies reveal existence of a liquid-liquid critical point. Other fascinating phenomena (protein glass transition, colloidal self assembly..) appear to involve some aspects of such a transition.


The colloquium culminated with the talk “The Elusive Neutrino” by Dr. Amol Dighe from Dept of Theoretical Physics, TIFR. The neutrinos needed to be studies as their enormous potential to reveal the secrets about the universe formation. They are found in nuclear reactors, in thermonuclear fusion in the corona of Sun, particle accelerators, cosmic rays, natural radioactivity, supernova i.e. stellar collapse etc. A neutrino which is thousand times lighter than electron and there has been no conclusive measurement about the physical properties of neutrino.


The role of neutrinos in stellar explosion was under investigation during Dr. Amol`s talk. If we could locate information about neutrino masses and mixing encoded in energy spectra of neutrinos; this combined with identification of neutrinos mass ordering either normal or inverted order can predict the supernova explosion hours before actual event. This is possible b y tracking the shock waves when still inside the mantle. The future of neutrino physics is concentrated in developing bigger and better detectors.


The eleventh plan of Government of India has envisaged foundation of Indian Neutrino Observatory near Mysore. Several groups belonging to different Universities and research Institutes in India are part of the collaboration working on the details of INO. The current proposal focuses on neutrino detection with static detectors, to be placed deep underground at a site close to Masinagudi in the Nilgiri mountains of South India.The research work in this direction will be based in Mysore. Dr. Dighe told that even if presently we are in a position to narrow down on hundred possible an excellent group of theorists making the physics case of INO strong, it is true that we need around 500 Physicists for this ambitious exercise. INO is an effort aimed at building a world-class underground laboratory to study fundamental issues in physics.


The primary goal of the laboratory is the study of neutrinos from various natural and laboratory sources. It is envisaged that such an underground facility will develop into a centre for other studies as well, in physics, biology, geology, etc., all of which will make use of the special conditions that exist deep underground. Apart from the scientific goals of INO, the laboratory itself will greatly enhance the development of detector technology and its varied applications.


Recent data from several neutrino detectors around the world, in particular, that from the Super-Kamiokande detector in Japan, and the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO) in Canada, seem to indicate that neutrinos not only have mass, but also experience flavour mixing. This leads to the phenomenon of neutrino oscillations that can then explain the discrepancy between theory and observation as seen in certain experiments. If correct, this will provide the first unambiguous evidence for physics beyond the so-called standard model of particle physics. The existence of nonzero neutrino masses has profound implications on fields as varied as nuclear physics, particle physics, astrophysics and cosmology. It is also important to note that with the observation of neutrinos from the core of the sun and also from the supernova SN1987A, a new window to the universe has opened up.


In future, neutrino astronomy is going to play a key role in our understanding of the universe. Most importantly, neutrino telescopes will allow us to look into the densest places of the universe which are completely opaque to optical astronomy. To exploit this emerging new area of observational neutrino physics, about two years ago, the idea to construct a neutrino detector at an India-based Neutrino Observatory (INO) was mooted.[1]


The first year of the project will be devoted to exploration, finalisation of designs, identifying the contractors, etc. The next two years will involve excavation of the tunnel and laboratory cavern. During the last two years installation of the laboratory equipment and detector construction will begin. The present road map envisages that the first module of the detector, 16 ktons, will start taking data at the end of five years. Immediately after that the subsequent modules will be constructed. This project is expected to be beyond 25 years of it`s functioning capacity.


This commemoration of the legendary scientist’s birth centenary marks the one more step in the direction of celebrating the ethos of scientific spirit represented by equally passionate interest he showed in music, literature, strategic thinking, administrative and bureaucratic acumen and above all belief that any Big science ultimately should benefit common men and women.


[1] NABA K MONDAL (2004), STATUS OF INDIA-BASED NEUTRINO OBSERVATORY (INO), Proc Indian Natn Sci Acad, 70, A, No.1, January 2004, pp.71–77

New Initiatives in Climate Change Research in India

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Many countries are blessed with internal and external security problems, constant conflicts leading towards loss of life and habitat, pervasion of chronic issues of hunger, poverty, lack of basic health facilities marred by void of education and human rights. In this context, the climate change is emerging as an issue of concern to all members of diverse societies, cultures, citizenships loaded with narrow differences and also having lot of similarities to share due to the common ecology and physical borders of those societies and countries.


To understand the processes of Climate Change, it requires a new holistic ‘paradigm shift’ in our thinking. When language of threats arising out of climate change is going through the prism of real, urgent and dangerous; the meaning reflected by these words have acquired definite meaning in the parlance of scientific evidence through consistent evolution of international consensus.


Lead originally by initiative of Indian Academy of Sciences and considering the importance of reliable science input on Climate Change for policy framework generated by The Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology (IITM) in the past on climate change research, Ministry of Earth Sciences (MoES) has set up a national Centre for Climate Change Research (CCCR) at IITM to address all science issues of Climate Change relevant to the regional climate. Centre could be seen at the link ‘CCCR’ of the Institute’s website: http://www.tropmet.res.in


The CCCR is a grant-in-aid Program at IITM as part of a larger National Program on Global and Regional Climate Change launched by the Ministry of Earth Sciences, Govt. India. IITM, Pune, an autonomous Institute under the MoES functioning as a leading research centre in applied and fundamental aspects of ocean-land-atmosphere interaction in tropics is searching for reputed scientists for senior scientific positions at different levels for its newly launched Centre for Climate Change


The Program will involve attribution and projection of regional monsoon climate using regional as well as high resolution global coupled models. R & D activity is planned to do whatever is needed to reduce the uncertainty in the attributions and projections. The Centre is envisioned to be a world centre of excellence with all the necessary physical and computing infrastructure as well as adequate human resources and will provide state-of-the-art work environment for scientists. Research (CCCR) at Pune.


The indicators reflecting the significance of the research in various variables are already moving beyond the patterns of natural variability within which contemporary society and economy have developed and thrived. Indicators include a) Global mean surface temperature, b)Sea level rise, c)Global ocean temperature, d) Arctic sea rise extent, e)Ocean acidification, f) Extreme climatic events. The Scientific expertise which CCRA is seeking to advance research in Climate Change in the areas of (i) Physical Processes, (ii) Climate Modelling, (iii) Climate Scenarios Development, (iv) Impact Assessment, and (v) Observed Changes and Data Products.


Studies of physical processes include improving various components of the global and regional models and ultimately the simulation of regional climate. In Climate Modeling the key issues will be development of coupled Ocean-Atmosphere, modeling strategy under different climate change scenarios, assessment of uncertainties in monsoon under climate change scenarios, assessment of the relative roles of aerosols and GHGs on Indian Monsoon, development of modeling set up to undertake various sensitivity studies and outstanding issues relevant to climate change and palaeoclimate modeling studies to identify climate analogues in the past for the estimate of future evolution of climate.


Forecasting constitutes crucial part of mitigating crisis which can occur due to extreme events of climate change. In this respect CCRA will try to establish fresh perspectives about Climate Scenarios Development. The chief objectives of it will be a) to generate an ensemble of high-resolution regional climate change scenarios to be utilized by several groups in the country that are involved with impact assessment and development of adaptation and mitigation policies and methodologies by running several global and regional climate models with different GHG scenarios for more than a century and b) to evaluate and develop suitable downscaling methodologies for developing tailor made climate change data products for the users in the country and the region.


India is lacking in informed studies of Impacts Assessments to convince the global community that country is equally vulnerable to the threats of dynamic changes in the ecosystem. Therefore, to examine the impact of climate change on some important sectors such as the water resources with a special emphasis on the Himalayan river systems, agriculture, human health etc new studies have been initiated. These studies will be done at the centre itself as well as in joint collaboration with other groups in the country.


The current crisis of climate change is arrived not only due to production of the GHGs in recent times but also due to long lasting accumulation of the GHGs since many decades. Because of the long life of Carbon Di Oxide, Methane, Nitrus Oxide and HFCs, PFCs, SF6 the accumulated concentration of the GHGs is causing cumulative impact on the environment. The world is having very small window of opportunity as far as mitigation and adaptation is concerned. If the consensus arrived around 2 degree Celsius is to be materialized then world must stop the concentration of CO2 upto 450 ppm. Right now the world has concentration of CO2 around 430 ppm. Regarding Observed Changes and Data Products the capacities to be developed in CCRA include following areas: (i) Monitoring, source identification of various GHGs, (ii) Aerosols; space time variability, chemical composition etc., (iii) Monitoring and assessing land use and land cover changes, and (iv) Palaeoclimate reconstruction using various proxies.


New ambitious mechanism of diffusion of technology must be developed in order to facilitate the developing countries for strengthening their hands in mitigating the damage being done by climate change. This mere access of technology will not solve the problem of the enhancing the mitigation efforts. There is urgent need to develop capacity building institutions in the developing countries, improved financial mechanisms, and whole set of development initiatives to improve the adaptable techniques to incorporate the modern technologies. Before moving in this direction, rigorous research in versatile aspects of fundamental sciences of climate change is very essential.



-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness..."

Report of 'South Asia Media Workshop on Climate Change' in New Delhi during 27-28th Aug. 09
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


“It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair, we had everything before us, we had nothing before us, we were all going direct to heaven, we were all going direct the other way …”
---From 'A Tale of Two Cities'




Is climate change new?
It is no surprise to imagine that Charles Dickens may have predicted the challenge of Climate Change few centuries ago in different literary jargons distinctly isolated from the language of science. But climate change is as old as the hills, oceans and forests. Anthropogenic climate change began to leave their imprints in human memory millions years ago. But development of our comprehensive approach towards Climate Change as a concept, phenomenon and discipline of study has only materialized recently.


Climate change is not environmental negotiation only. It is also form of very competitive economic negotiations. The variant patterns and changing trends of climate change should be communicated by scientists inheriting the spirit of investigative journalist. Because it is a dynamic science. So everyone involved has a right to know about the impacts of the climate change, the processes which are very difficult to decipher and discern the true meaning of particular event by conventional benchmarks of inquiry.


To understand the processes of Climate Change, it requires a new holistic paradigm shift in our thinking. When language of threats arising out of climate change is going through the prism of real, urgent and dangerous the meaning reflected by these words have acquired definite meaning in the parlance of scientific evidence.


The current crisis of climate change is arrived not only due to production of the GHGs in recent times but also due to long lasting accumulation of the GHGs since many decades. Because of the long life of Carbon Di Oxide, Methane, Nitrus Oxide and HFCs, PFCs, SF6 the accumulated concentration of the GHGs is causing cumulative impact on the environment. The world is having very small window of opportunity as far as mitigation and adaptation is concerned. If the consensus arrived around 2 degree Celsius is to be materialized then world must stop the concentration of CO2 upto 450 ppm. Right now the world has concentration of CO2 around 430 ppm.


So there is very little room for maneuvering to compromise the interest of the world. In essence, the disturbance in the natural carbon cycle (emission and sinking and level of precipitation) is causing the driver of climate change. The upcoming risk is related to natural carbon dioxide sinks becoming weak in the future because of effects of increasing ocean acidification, ocean circulation changes. As warming amplifies, previously inert pools of carbon could release more GHGs.


Many key climate indicators are already moving beyond the patterns of natural variability within which contemporary society and economy have developed and thrived. Indicators include a) Global mean surface temperature, b)Sea level rise, c)Global ocean temperature, d) Arctic sea rise extent, e)Ocean acidification, f) Extreme climatic events


The rediscovery of the concept of the growth:
It is must to remember that no country in the world has ever built a low carbon economy. The whole debate of the negotiating processes is about sharing the growth by cooperation having equity and fairness. These are very much the prerequisites for the effective climate change agreement. The acceptance of two degree centigrade limit may be one of the aspects of criticism leveled towards leadership of developing countries but it is equally important to understand that Annex one counters in UNFCC framework are pushing for capping the development processes to contribute to the success of negotiations taking shape towards the commencement of Copenhagen summit.


The technical point concerned with the argument of “Need to have equal space to grow” can be explained by the Carbon budget of the world which is estimated by the experts for the period of 1850-2050. As per this budget, out of total World Carbon Budget which is around 650 Giga Tonnes of Carbon, Annex one countries have already consumed 209 GTC in advance during the course of industrialization and reindustrialization period. If we calculate the proportion of the carbon budget to be spent for the developing countries according to the population they have surpassed their share. They should get around 137 GTC which is very much less than what they have expended around 209 GTC. So in order to reverse this allocation, it requires enormous effort and level of commitment for mitigation and adaptation. This excess level of emissions crossing beyond their legitimate right based on population is largely due to their lifestyle and consumption patterns.


From Bali to Copenhagen through Poznan:
Despite evolving framework of regular conventions adopted, emphasized and debated during the recent times, there is no substantial progress made by Annex One countries (majority developed countries) towards mitigation. The share of the cumulative emissions globally has been demonstrated by consistent negation of the principle of ‘Right to Live’ inherited by the vast population (80%) of the developing and least developed countries. This population of south is consuming five times less energy than those of developed world. The figures speak for themselves: USA: 28 %, EU-25.23 %, China 9%, Japan 5%, Canada 2%, Australia 2%, India 2%, Mexico and Brazil 2%, South Korea and Indonesia 2%, Rest of the World 26% (primarily former soviet block and Africa). Significantly the share of the emissions of Annex one countries has risen in the recent time more than the figures just demonstrated for the period of 1950 to 2000.


Currently India is accounting for 2 tonnes of Carbon per capita emission compared to global average level of 4 tonnes/capita. So we are still growing at modest pace. Despite the fact that some Indian publications commented that Indian government compromised their stand at LaKila Major Economic Forum summit held in Italy recently, India has given substantial commitment to international community that “at not point during the phase of ascending economic growth we will allow to grow our emissions beyond the average emissions/capita that of developed countries.”


A 2007 review of the UNFCC found that between 1990s and 2006, while CO2 emissions of all industrialized nations declined by 1.3 per cent, this decline was primarily due to the low emissions of countries whose economies were in transition. If these nations were excluded, CO2 emissions of rich counties had actually increased by 14.5 percent. Throughout the different agreements and negotiations of 1988, 1992, 1997 responsibility was clearly identified for the Annex one countries for the concerned emission cuts. But they were consistently pushing for OFFSET mitigation mechanisms.


The whole politics of the emissions currently is concentrated around the arguments to decide the base line for the starting of the emission level reduction. Therefore developed countries are playing new game of introducing enhanced emission reduction targets by increasing the base line year beyond 2000. For instance, USA wants to commit itself for 20 % emission cuts unto 2020 having base line 2005, EU is pushing for 20-30% on 1990 level, Japan 7 % on 1990, Australia for 5-15 etc. Rich countries are accounting for seven of every ten tonnes of CO2 since the start of industrial era.


The fact is that the increasing the base line and increasing the percentage of emission reduction targets will compel us to forget the cumulative increase of the emissions and their reflections in the cumulative increase in the proportion of the total emissions. So even the modest target for the Annex one countries is set to reduce 40 % of the total emissions around the 1990 level to be achieved by 2020, this is very less than what is required to stall the march of impending crisis. This is to be remembered that target has be achieved without any room of OFFSETs by Annex one countries by investing in developing countries. Currently whatever percentage of emission reduction developed world has achieved the primary and major share has been of OFFSETs in terms of CDMs and other bypasses. Of the total emission reductions, EU is gaining 66 % and USA is earning 75% emissions from the OFFSETs. This is against the principle of the UNFCC. There is no domestically enhanced, substantial effort in the Annex one countries which proves the seriousness of those countries in achieving the relevant and practically achievable targets set for emission reduction.


Upto August 2009, there were total 4200 CDM projects which were in pipeline. Out of these, 1774 were registered projects. Out of total projects, 73% are being run in Asia Pacific region. The deals of CDM projects are very secretive and public access to information to these agreements is not satisfactory. The OFFSETTing pattern shows that there is no real effort to invest in the clean energy. CDM transaction volumes have been small and falling by 30 %. But contrary to these reports of decline in the prospects of CDM, the market for Carbon driven applications in industries and other technologies increased by US $ 126 billion. This is primarily due to Spot shares and futures trading. The mushrooming of the start ups related to new renewable are suffocating due to lack of capital and also due to the recent financial crisis, which is here to stay in coming months. World has witnessed that due to recent ambitious start ups in bio-diesel, huge population of the developing world has experienced shock of extreme food crisis.


Energy:
The options in front of developing countries to increase their preparedness for the challenge of mitigation involve moving towards renewable, adopting standard practices of Energy Efficiency and moving towards modern technologies of mitigation (expensive Integrated Classification Combustion Cycle, Carbon Sequestration and Deposition Techniques). The tools of CLF remain competitive but the capital cost for these still remain high. Dealing with all these problems of access to technology, complexities of technology transfer and criticalities of IPR regime it has to be emphasized again and again that Climate Change is not linear science.


When 39 % of India`s primary energy is coming from the chullahs burning the biomass(black carbon) and when renewable now accounting to only one % of the total energy generation there is fierce initiative from the Annex one countries to divert the debate towards the “damage” done by the carbon emitted by biomass combustion in the developing countries where nearly two third of the population is still bereft of any commercialized energy resources which potentially lead to less carbon emissions. To date, 78 % of world`s primary energy comes from the burning of biomass. Question is whether do poors of the world really contribute to the climate change? Answer is confident NO!


The majority of the developing countries are in the process of building their energy, transport and infrastructure. In the energy sector transportation has been one of the biggest contributor jumping by 18 % of the total emissisons, There is no energy transformation archived in developed countries as yet. Still India and China along with other non-Annex countries can invest in leapfrog technologies which are efficient, green and affordable. India`s Total Primary Energy Supply/capita is 0.5 while that of OECD is 4.7 and China 1.4. The electricity consumption of India is 503 units per capita while that of OECD us 8381 and China amounting to 2040 units per capita.


In the region every country is blessed with internal and external security problems, constant conflicts leading towards loss of life and habitat, pervasion of chronic issues of huger, poverty, lack of basic health facilities marred by void of education and human rights, the climate change is emerging as an issue of concern to all members of diverse societies, cultures, citizenships loaded with narrow differences and also having lot of similarities to share due to the common ecology shared by the physical borders of those societies and countries.


Challenges:
The number of glaciers on the part of Indian Himalayan ranges increased due to fragmentation. Larger glaciers have become lesss in number and smaller ones have increased. Glaciers at lower attitudes are retreating faster. Rivers are carrying more water from glaciers in winter and in some cases the glacial melt in summer has decreased.


New ambitious mechanism of diffusion of technology must be developed in order to facilitate the developing countries for strengthening their hands in mitigating the damage being done by climate change. This mere access of technology will not solve the problem of the enhancing the mitigation efforts. There is urgent need to develop capacity building institutions in the developing countries, improved financial mechanisms, and whole set of development initiatives to improve the adaptable techniques to incorporate the modern technologies. The question of IPRs is daunting one. There is much discussion about the accelerated technology transfer. We need to know about what exactly accelerated means?


According to one of the reports prepared by the International Consultancy, it is predicted that the world is having 70 % of it`s technologies to achieve 40 % upto the emission redcution level. All the efforts taken in this direction must be pragmatic i.e. measurable, reportable and verifiable. Achieving the harmony in the developement and adaptation is the big task and this can be countered by embedding their climate change strategies in the sustainable developmental processes.


There are much more complex challenges of urgent priorities and commitments. Effective financing and resource delivery is one of the big tasks lying ahead. During the generation of the resources the aspects of adequacy and scale will play important role apart from criteria of additional cost benefit and public entitlement. In all the priorities of the demand, supply and delivery the key features standing out are: adequacy, predictability, automatically, degree of levy on transactions. Rational for enhanced financial flows are evolved from adaptation cost studies by developing more and more information.


Additionality measures include climate proofing, mangrove covers, early warning systems, crop insurance schemes, tracking and preventing the spread of communicable diseases etc.. There is increasing thinking about normal development approaches to be practiced as the adaptation strategy. So there is inherent challenge to address the paradox between development initiatives and adaptation strategies. Some of the additionalities which may form the part of development processes are Risk management, constant dissemination of information, building excellent research capabilities, capacity building, concrete measures of co-financing, financing multilateral interventions etc. Delivery management is also important part of these processes where role of government, different institutions, marketing and supply institutions.


Merit Good !
We have been consistently experiencing that market cannot deliver the merit good. But it does not mean that market does not have potential to provide that. But in the game of Climate Change negotiations apart from Civil Society, Markets have definitely emerged as a decisive factor influencing the process of bargaining. Let us wait for the Copenhagen to imprint its historical significance by expressing the obligation towards Common but differentiated responsibilities. We need action for the words spoken by world and already advocated throughout the treaties in terms of letter and spirit.


Considering the fact that Kyoto Protocol was a pledge and review agreement; eventhough Kyoto Protocol came into force in 2005, the rules for a penalty for non-compliance or failure to meet targets were never conclusively negotiated. Next, Bali action plan was based on four main pillars of mitigation, adaptation, finance and technology. It is important that a agreement is reached concerning all these pillars. Consensus on these pillars will determine the extent of success to be realised in the agreement of Copenhegan.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------